Simulation theory is apparently what happens when believing in an unseen intelligence becomes reasonable again, provided we give it a computer.

We might live in a world constructed by beings above us. They might possess technology so advanced that generating an entire universe is possible. They might have created us, established the rules of our existence, and arranged events within the world we experience.

Fine. But why is this supposed to be a more credible alternative to God?

You still have an intelligence beyond our experienced reality. You still have a world whose existence depends upon it. You still have beings inside that world trying to understand whoever put them there. Adding technological vocabulary does not establish any of those claims. It just makes them sound more familiar to someone who already likes technology.

What Have You Actually Established?

The argument usually moves from our ability to create simulations to the possibility that a much more advanced civilization could create one containing conscious people. If enough civilizations did that, perhaps simulated observers would vastly outnumber everyone else.

But the conclusion depends upon the things being proposed actually being possible. Can computation produce consciousness? Can a civilization develop the required technology? Would it survive long enough, want to do this, and produce the number of simulations the argument needs?

These are conditions to establish, not achievements we can attribute to imaginary civilizations and then use as evidence that those civilizations probably created us.

“Maybe there is something above us that is so technically advanced that running a universe simulation is possible and common.” That is essentially the proposal. Describing what an unknown being might be capable of does not demonstrate its capabilities.

Of course, someone could object that Christians also believe in someone beyond the world. Yes. That is exactly why presenting simulation theory as though it has escaped that kind of claim is so funny. You have not escaped it. You have offered another version, and yours needs an argument too.

The Simulator Still Needs an Explanation

There is also a fairly obvious problem with the proposed explanation. Where does the simulator live?

Presumably in some reality where beings, computers, and whatever passes for physical laws already exist. So even if you established that our world was simulated, you would still have to explain the reality making the simulation possible.

“That world is simulated too” only moves the question back again. We can keep adding computers. Eventually someone still has to explain why there is anything there to run them.

This is where the resemblance to Christianity stops being an equivalence. God is not a technically advanced creature living one floor above us. Christianity identifies Him as the uncreated source of existence itself. A simulator would be another thing requiring an explanation. It could explain how our environment was generated without explaining why reality exists.

That would still be a significant discovery, obviously. It just would not have replaced God. You would have discovered another layer of creation.

Try Running Christianity Through the Same Language

Suppose we take the comparison seriously. Our world depends upon an intelligence beyond it. Its order comes from that intelligence. Events occur within its governance. The intelligence can make itself known to the people inhabiting the world.

Now say the intelligence is God, the world is His creation, and its history unfolds within His providence. He enters that history as Jesus Christ, and the outcome is what Christianity proclaims.

What have we produced? Christianity, described through a technological analogy.

Calling it a simulation has not added an explanation. We have taken the same claims and slightly modified the vocabulary. If we want a genuinely different account, something substantive has to change.

Perhaps the creator becomes a finite experimenter. Perhaps we exist for entertainment. Perhaps our suffering matters to nobody outside the system. The popular version can retain the idea of a creator while removing the relationship Christianity says we have with Him.

Simulation theory does not require its creators to be cruel or indifferent. It simply has not established who they are or what they want. But that leaves the obvious question: why replace the God Christianity claims has revealed Himself with unknown beings whose existence and intentions remain speculative?

You can argue that Christianity’s claims are false. But replacing them with “maybe a sufficiently advanced civilization did it” has not, by itself, made your position better supported.

Why Call It a Glitch?

Then there are the coincidences people attribute to the simulation. Something happens at exactly the right moment. Two unrelated events converge. A conversation answers a question someone has been carrying around for weeks.

“A glitch in the matrix.” Why? What established that anything malfunctioned?

The event happened. Its timing seemed significant. That is what you observed. The computer, the programmer, and the glitch are your proposed explanation. None came attached to the event.

From the Christian understanding, the world already exists within God’s providence. There is no need to introduce a hidden computer to account for the possibility that events have meaning beyond what we immediately understand.

That does not mean every coincidence is a private message from God. We can misread things. We can notice a pattern because we are looking for it. But the same restraint applies to the person finding evidence of programming in everything unusual.

An ordinary explanation also does not put an event outside providence. God does not become involved only when something inexplicable happens. If He sustains creation, ordinary causes already operate within the reality He sustains.

So the Christian does not need to deny the experience that interested the simulation theorist. The disagreement is over what accounts for it. Calling it a glitch has not settled that disagreement.

What Does the Simulation Add?

My objection is not that the idea is too extraordinary to discuss. Christianity makes extraordinary claims. The question is whether an account is coherent and whether we have good reasons to accept it.

Simulation theory often receives credit for its scientific appearance before the things it requires have been established. Meanwhile, Christianity is dismissed for appealing to a reality beyond us. Yet the proposed alternative appeals to unknown superior beings and unknown technology capable of producing our entire experienced world.

If that is the alternative, then let’s actually compare the accounts. What explains existence? What explains the proposed creator? What grounds our significance? What reasons do we have to believe the account is true?

A computer cannot answer those questions simply by being a computer.

And if we keep the Christian answers while calling creation a simulation, we have not reasoned beyond Christianity. We have renamed it.

You can call providence programming if you want. You still have to explain who is doing it, why they exist, and why we should believe your account of them.

THE END / 06