The Conditions of Intelligibility
This opening stage establishes the method used by Parts II–IV. Its ten theses form a deliberate progression, while remaining independently readable.
-
01
↗
The Necessity of Logic
Every rational argument necessarily employs logical principles.
-
02
↗
The Authority of Logic
Logical principles provide standards by which reasoning can be judged correct or incorrect.
-
03
↗
The Universality of Logic
Logical validity is not reducible to individual acceptance, location, or preference.
-
04
↗
The Problem of Universals
An adequate account must explain how distinct particulars share intelligible characteristics.
-
05
↗
The One and the Many
Reality contains both unity and plurality; neither may simply be eliminated.
-
06
What Makes an Explanation Adequate?
Explanations may be compared by coherence, scope, justification, economy, and evidence.
-
07
The Burden of Explanation
Calling something fundamental does not automatically make it explanatorily adequate.
-
08
The Impossibility of Neutrality
Inquiry always employs standards of reasoning, evidence, and justification.
-
09
The Internal Critique
A worldview may be tested according to the implications of its own commitments.
-
10
The More Coherent Worldview
Rational inquiry permits justified preference among competing explanations.