TRUTH & WAY / AN INDEPENDENT JOURNALFAITH. REASON. CULTURE.
← All theses
Logic

The Necessity of Logic

Every argument presupposes logic.

The argument

Every argument presupposes logic.

To assert that something is true is to distinguish it from what is false. To disagree is to maintain that one conclusion should be accepted rather than another. To offer evidence is to assume that reasons can support conclusions.

Even the person who denies the authority of logic must employ reasoning to make that denial intelligible.

Consider the claim, “Logic is not necessary.”

If the claim is intended as a rational conclusion, it depends upon the very principles it attempts to dismiss. If it is not intended as a rational conclusion, it offers no rational grounds for accepting it.

This does not mean that every system of formal logic is identical, or that every disputed logical principle is beyond examination.

It means that rational argument cannot dispense with logical standards altogether.

Logic is not something we can reject through reasoning without relying upon reasoning itself.

Syllogism

P1.

Every rational argument necessarily employs some logical principles.

P2.

A rational argument against the necessity of all logical principles would itself employ some logical principles.

C.

Therefore, no rational argument can consistently reject the necessity of all logical principles.

Rebuttal

One may object that logic is merely a human convention: a set of rules invented to organize thought rather than something objectively necessary.

But even if particular logical systems are conventional, the objection itself must distinguish valid from invalid reasoning and support its conclusion through some intelligible relationship between premises and conclusion.

The conventionalist can dispute which logical principles are correct. They cannot coherently argue that no logical principles are necessary for rational argument while expecting their argument to carry rational force.

A second objection appeals to nonclassical logics, some of which reject principles traditionally regarded as universal.

But disagreement between logical systems does not demonstrate that reasoning can occur without logic. It demonstrates that the appropriate principles of logic remain subjects of philosophical investigation.

The argument establishes something narrower and more fundamental: reasoning necessarily operates according to logical constraints, whatever their correct formulation may be.

We cannot reason our way outside reason.

Sources

  • Aristotle, Metaphysics, Book IV, chapters 3–4 — The principle of noncontradiction and its defense.
  • Aristotle, Prior Analytics, Book I — The structure of deductive reasoning.
  • Graham Priest, An Introduction to Non-Classical Logic — Alternative logical systems and their principles.
FIND AN ESSAY
TRUTH & WAY

A journal of
first things.

Independent thoughts of Jacob Lyon on faith, reason, culture, and the things that make us human.

Enter the reading room ↗