TRUTH & WAY / AN INDEPENDENT JOURNALFAITH. REASON. CULTURE.
Cumulative structure · Completed Part 1 of IV
The Foundations · The first stage of the cumulative argument

The Conditions of Intelligibility

This opening stage establishes the method used by Parts II–IV. Its ten theses form a deliberate progression, while remaining independently readable.

  1. 01

    The Necessity of Logic

    Every rational argument necessarily employs logical principles.

    ↗
  2. 02

    The Authority of Logic

    Logical principles provide standards by which reasoning can be judged correct or incorrect.

    ↗
  3. 03

    The Universality of Logic

    Logical validity is not reducible to individual acceptance, location, or preference.

    ↗
  4. 04

    The Problem of Universals

    An adequate account must explain how distinct particulars share intelligible characteristics.

    ↗
  5. 05

    The One and the Many

    Reality contains both unity and plurality; neither may simply be eliminated.

    ↗
  6. 06

    What Makes an Explanation Adequate?

    Explanations may be compared by coherence, scope, justification, economy, and evidence.

  7. 07

    The Burden of Explanation

    Calling something fundamental does not automatically make it explanatorily adequate.

  8. 08

    The Impossibility of Neutrality

    Inquiry always employs standards of reasoning, evidence, and justification.

  9. 09

    The Internal Critique

    A worldview may be tested according to the implications of its own commitments.

  10. 10

    The More Coherent Worldview

    Rational inquiry permits justified preference among competing explanations.

FIND AN ESSAY
TRUTH & WAY

A journal of
first things.

Independent thoughts of Jacob Lyon on faith, reason, culture, and the things that make us human.

Enter the reading room ↗